The comparison that actually matters
Disposable razors and a reusable shaving set solve the same problem, but they differ in what you replace and how often. Disposables are designed to be thrown away after a few shaves. A set like the Public Goods Shaving Set gives you a handle you keep and blades you swap. The real question is not which one shaves better on day one, but which one makes sense for your routine over months and years.
This comparison focuses on cost structure, waste, and the practical details you can verify from the product information. It does not assume a specific number of shaves per blade or a fixed replacement schedule, because those depend on your hair, technique, and how often you shave.
How the two options differ
The table below compares the two approaches on the factors that affect your decision. It uses only what is stated in the supplied product information for the Public Goods Shaving Set.
- What you buy once vs. repeatedly: A disposable razor is a single unit you use and discard. The Public Goods Shaving Set includes a bamboo razor handle, four razor blades, and a 6 oz shaving cream. The handle is the reusable part; blades and cream are consumables.
- Waste profile: Disposable razors create plastic waste with each discarded razor. A reusable handle reduces the frequency of handle disposal, but blades still need replacement. The supplied information does not state blade material or recyclability, so treat waste reduction as partial rather than zero.
- Upfront cost vs. long-term cost: The Public Goods Shaving Set is listed at USD 30.71 (catalog comparison price USD 40.95). Disposable razors typically have a lower upfront cost per unit, but the total cost depends on how often you replace them. The set's long-term cost depends on how long the handle lasts and how often you buy replacement blades and cream, which the supplied information does not quantify.
- Shave cream included: The set includes a moisturizing shave cream formulated to cushion and hydrate the skin. Disposable razors usually do not include cream, so that is an extra purchase to factor in.
- Skin and body compatibility: The set is described as designed for use across all skin types and routines and suitable for all genders and body types. Disposable razors vary widely; check the individual product for similar claims.
What the Public Goods Shaving Set includes
- Shaving Set: Set includes a Bamboo Razor Handle, four Razor Blades and a 6oz Shaving Cream. This is the baseline for comparing against disposables: one reusable handle, four blades, and cream. You can estimate how long four blades last based on your shaving frequency, then compare replacement costs.

Shaving Set - Shaving Set: The trio includes a bamboo razor handle, replacement blades, and a moisturizing shave cream formulated to cushion and hydrate the skin. The cream is part of the set, so the upfront price covers more than just the razor. When comparing to disposables, add the cost of shave cream to the disposable razor price for a fair comparison.
- Shaving Set: Designed for use across all skin types and routines, the set brings together simple tools for a clean, comfortable result. This claim helps if you have sensitive skin or want a set that does not require choosing a specialized formula. It is a general suitability statement, not a guarantee for every individual.
Cost over time: what you can and cannot calculate
A safety razor cost comparison often assumes a fixed number of shaves per blade, but that number varies. The Public Goods Shaving Set comes with four blades. If you shave daily, you might replace a blade every week or two; if you shave twice a week, a blade could last longer. Without a stated blade lifespan, any long-term cost estimate is a range, not a precise figure.
What you can do is compare the structure. Disposables require buying a new razor each time, which includes a new handle and blade. The set requires buying only blades and cream after the initial purchase. Over time, that can reduce cost if the handle holds up and you buy blades in economical packs. The supplied information does not list replacement blade prices or handle warranty, so check the store for current details before relying on a long-term savings claim.
The catalog comparison price of USD 40.95 versus the listed USD 30.71 suggests a discount, but prices change. Use the current price at checkout for your own comparison.
Waste considerations for plastic razor alternatives
If reducing plastic waste is your main reason for considering a reusable set, keep these points in mind.
- Handle disposal is reduced, not eliminated: A bamboo handle is designed to be kept, so you are not throwing away a plastic handle with every few shaves. However, the handle will eventually wear out or break, and the supplied information does not state its lifespan or end-of-life disposal guidance.
- Blades are still consumable: The set includes four razor blades. Replacement blades are necessary, and their packaging and material are not described in the supplied information. Look for blade recycling options if that matters to you.
- Cream packaging: The 6 oz shaving cream comes in a container. The supplied information does not specify the packaging material or recyclability. Disposable razors often come with no cream, so you would buy cream separately either way, but the set's cream is part of the initial purchase.
- Net waste depends on your replacement frequency: If you replace disposable razors frequently, a reusable handle likely reduces plastic waste. If you already stretch disposable razors for many shaves, the difference may be smaller.
Shave quality and routine fit
Disposable razors are convenient and require no learning curve. A reusable handle with replacement blades may feel different in the hand, and the bamboo handle has a different weight and grip than plastic. The supplied information does not describe the handle's weight, grip texture, or blade angle, so we cannot say how it compares in feel.
The set includes a moisturizing shave cream, which can improve glide compared to shaving with soap or water alone. If you already have a shave cream you like, the included cream may be redundant, but it does make the set a complete starter kit.
For travel, disposables are often lighter and can be discarded before the return trip. A reusable set requires packing the handle and blades, and you need to consider whether blades are allowed in carry-on luggage depending on your destination's rules. The supplied information does not cover travel restrictions.
A practical way to decide
Use these questions to choose between the two options for your situation.
- How often do you shave?: Frequent shavers may benefit more from a reusable handle because they go through blades quickly. Infrequent shavers may find disposables sufficient and simpler.
- Do you want a complete kit?: The Public Goods Shaving Set includes handle, four blades, and cream. If you prefer to buy everything at once and not think about separate cream purchases, that is a point in its favor.
- Is plastic waste a priority?: A reusable handle reduces plastic handle waste. If that is important to you, the set is a step in that direction, though blades still need disposal.
- Do you need portability?: Disposables are easier to pack and discard. A reusable set is better for a fixed routine at home.
- Have you checked replacement costs?: Before committing, look up the price of replacement blades for the Public Goods handle. The supplied information does not include that price, so check the store listing.
What the supplied information does not tell you
The product information does not state how many shaves a blade lasts, the handle's expected lifespan, or the price of replacement blades. It also does not specify the blade material, recyclability, or the packaging of the cream. These are important for a full cost and waste comparison, so treat any long-term savings estimate as approximate. For the most accurate picture, check the current product page for updated details and pricing.
Disposable razors also vary widely in price and blade count, so compare like with like. A cheap disposable may cost less upfront but require more frequent replacement. The right choice depends on your shaving habits and priorities.

